Home Blog Page 34

Sunset Beach artist Bill Anderson celebrates Gallery’s 30th Anniversary

By Chris MacDonald

Bill Anderson, owner of Anderson Art Gallery, is celebrating 30 years of business in Sunset Beach next to Captain Jack’s Restaurant on Pacific Coast Highway. That’s quite a feat when so many other art galleries have come and gone through the decades.

“Bill Anderson is one of the most celebrated plein air painters living in California and we are honored to have his small and welcoming gallery here,” said Sunset Beach Community Association member Dawn McCormack.

With 75 paintings on permanent display at The Joint Forces Training Base in Los Alamitos and his artwork shown in galleries worldwide, Anderson doesn’t mind the fact that many locals drive by not noticing his building and signs. He welcomes national and international travelers who know of his work and fame, making appointments to visit him and see his original art, as well as the works of other famed artists he represents such as Milford Zornes and Mexican artist Raul Anguiano.

When Bill was teaching at McAuliffe Middle School in Los Alamitos back in 1994 he drove home daily on PCH in Sunset Beach where he noticed a “For Rent” sign above an interesting, old building next to Captain Jack’s restaurant. When he got home he told his wife Ausma that he thought it would be a great place for an art gallery and she agreed, so they signed a one year lease. That was 30 years ago!

With the intention of showing his work and a few other artists, the couple had no problem filling the walls of their new gallery. They had some works of Raul Anguiano who lived three months of the year in Huntington Harbour but spent most his time in Mexico. Anderson also knew Milford Zornes, the well-known water colorist recognized as a leader in the California Style watercolor movement which began in the early 1930’s. He also displayed works by known, local sculptors and artists such as Howard Hitchcock, Tino Pontrelli, Harvey Clemans and Lynn Morgan. You can still see some of those artists (and others) represented in Anderson Art Gallery today.

Captain Jack’s owner Tim Haley loves the gallery and great watercolors, including several paintings of his famous seafood restaurant. “Mr. Anderson and his gallery together add a touch of class to our great community,” he said.

Sunset Beach resident Elaine Bakker said: “Long time residents are so appreciative of his interest & support in our local youth and their artistic endeavors. Not only has he taught art in schools, but he also contributes paintings and books to fundraisers for our community scholarships.”

Bill Anderson majored in Art in College and taught Art in High School and Jr. High School and Middle School in a 38 year career. He was very involved in Huntington Beach Art for a period of time and was on the Allied Arts Board for 12 years. As president of the board he had the idea of moving the Art Center to a separate building not in the Library and suggested getting the Southern California Edison building which is where the Huntington Beach Art Center is currently located. His successful presentation to City Council resulted in the the Art Center opening in that location.

Former Huntington Beach Mayor Bob Mandic said:” I awarded Bill Anderson Artist of The Year 40 Years ago when I was Mayor. Bill and his Gallery continue as an Iconic Treasure in our beach town.”

Anderson’s Gallery in Sunset Beach.
Courtesy photo

Bill has published 20 books, including 15 books of his artwork and 5 illustrated stories of the Old West by the late historian Craig MacDonald.
The Gallery is open Friday and Saturday from 1pm to 9pm and Sunday from 1pm to 6pm. You can call Bill anytime at (714) 272-1400. His e-mail is: aa***********@*ol.com.

Cypress Festival Board issues statement on political booths removal

Dear Cypress Community,

We would first like to acknowledge our mistake in selecting October 12th as the date of this year’s 43rd Annual Cypress Community Festival. When the Festival Committee, in partnership with the City of Cypress Recreation Department, selected and approved this date, we consulted our local school calendars and our city’s events calendar. Unfortunately, neither of these calendars list this holiday.

This is no excuse, and we acknowledge and apologize for this oversight on our part. Our board has implemented new procedures for date selection, moving forward to ensure that this does not happen in the future. We sympathize with the Jewish community and extend our apologies for this oversight.

With regard to the presence of political booths, the Festival Board of Directors has discussed the recent discourse happening online and in the city council chambers. Our board held a vote to decide what action to take. At this time, our board has decided that removing all candidate political booths from the 2024 festival is the best course of action. Making the difficult, but right, decision to remove these booths from our festival just weeks before the event will result in a budget deficit of $4,000 for our non-profit. Refunds for those candidates and organizations who had already signed up and paid their booth fees will be sent out within the next two weeks.

It is important to note that city staff attends our board meetings and was well aware of the date chosen and the presence of political booths many months before concerns were brought up. We are disappointed and disheartened that our communication and partnership with the city, specifically the mayor, city council and senior leadership, seems to have eroded over the past several weeks.

Many assumptions, accusations, and statements were made about our organization and our board that were untrue and/or unnecessary. Our board will address these concerns with the council and city staff privately as we don’t believe it benefits anyone to contribute to the divisive and aggressive conversations happening publicly online.

Lastly, we’d like the community to be aware that the Cypress Community Festival Association is a non-profit 501c4 organization made up of residents and business owners who volunteer their time for this event. None of these volunteers are paid, and many take on this position in addition to full time jobs, kids, families and very busy lives. The majority of our funding each year comes from booth fees, sponsorships, and sales of items at the event (chili ballots, alcohol, kids rides, etc.). Please reach out to us if you’re interested in joining our board and helping us secure more support and funding or helping us plan this event in years to come!

In closing, the Cypress Community Festival is a place for our community to come together and celebrate the birthday of the City of Cypress. We love and appreciate this beautiful and diverse community that we call home. The Festival Committee has been working very hard all year to plan this event and we hope to see you there! This year we have a great entertainment lineup, featuring Knyght Rider as our headlining band! We have a large selection of craft booths, a robust chili & salsa competition, a redesigned (and better priced) kids area, booths showcasing our local businesses, a classic car show, and our very own Cypress PD K-9 Bono demo team. The Festival will be open this year from 10am – 8pm with free shuttle service from Cypress High School.

On behalf of our board, thank you for your continued support.
Jimmy Fuller & Brittney Cook
President & Vice President

Editor’s Note: This statement was published unedited as received.

Who needs national politics when we have Cypress Mayor Scott Minikus

Last week’s Cypress City Council meeting was one for the record books – and possibly for the law books.

Buried in the meeting’s agenda was a “carry over” expenditure of $5,000 to be paid to the independent, non-profit organization that runs the city’s community festival. It was described as support for income that the festival organizers “lost” due to their last-minute decision to ban/eliminate “political booths” (which had already been reserved and paid for) by several local candidates running for the two open spots on the council in the November election.

While this may sound like a small, well-intentioned and supportive city expenditure, the story behind it reveals a dark, calculated and politically motivated misuse of public funds and abuse of power.

Statements made during the Cypress City Council meeting on September 23rd revealed that Mayor Scott Minikus, had met in person with the festival’s organizers bringing along city attorney Fred Gallante. At this meeting, the Mayor asked the organizers to eliminate the political booths because the festival date coincided with that of the Jewish high holiday of Yom Kippur, which would prevent one of the candidates, Mark Plager, from hosting one of the political booths at the festival.

It was further revealed by Mr. Plager himself that he had asked the Mayor to intervene on his behalf with the organizers to eliminate the political booths. Mr. Plager asked Mayor Minikus to “do it quietly behind closed doors”. It should be noted – and is in the public record – that Mayor Minikus is a big supporter of Mr. Plager’s campaign, as are Mayor Pro Tem Bonnie Peat and her husband Jon Peat, is Mr. Plager’s campaign treasurer. This kind of closed door action is the antithesis of how our government should operate.
This ugly story doesn’t end here.

Based on the agenda item and the statements made at the council meeting, it appears that Mayor Minikus suggested that the city compensate the festival with the above mentioned $5,000 in taxpayer funds in return for the booth fees they would lose by eliminating the “political booths”. This kind of expenditure doesn’t happen simply because the Mayor wants it to; he needs the support of the City Manager – Peter Grant – and other city staff to include the expenditure proposal on the council’s agenda in the “fine print” and have it approved.

Fortunately, that didn’t happen. Councilman David Burke objected and exposed the Mayor’s and city attorney’s roles in influencing the festival organizers to remove the political booths. He also objected to the wording of agenda item number seven (7) that purported to justify the expenditure of taxpayer funds in exchange for eliminating the political booths.

In the end, the council then voted to okay the expenditure but removed all wording indicating the payment was in exchange for the organizer’s elimination of the political booths. The vote was three to two, with Burke, Mallari and Marquez voting for and Mayor Minikus and his long-time supporter, Mayor Pro Tem Peat voting against. It was clarified that the festival organizers should henceforth be free to make their own decision regarding the presence of political booths at the festival.

Further aggravating this nasty chapter of Cypress city politics, the Mayor promulgated a set of flimsy arguments in defense of his actions, and launched a threatening outburst directed at Councilman Burke. The Mayor’s actions laid bare the entire ugly abuse of his influence in front of the council and attendees. However, that was definitely not the Mayor’s first or only threatening outburst. He was reprimanded by the council for his January 2024 outburst in which he accused, without any substantiating evidence, fellow council members Marquez and Burke for allegedly working with the plaintiffs in the CVRA lawsuit that the city eventually settled out of court for approximately $850,000, not including attorney’s fees and costs, all paid with taxpayer money

At the previous council meeting on September 9, 2024, the Mayor also threatened the citizens of Cypress regarding the content of their social media posts – especially as those applied to criticism of the current council majority and council candidates they support.
I want to ask the Cypress City Council to again, publicly, reprimand Mayor Minikus for this misuse of his position as Mayor and his violation of the council’s own code of civil conduct in his threatening verbal attack of Councilman Burke. In addition, I think the Mayor, the city attorney and city manager all owe the independent, volunteer, non-profit organizers of the Cypress Community Festival an apology.

Paul Kokkinos is a concerned resident and registered voter in Cypress

Griffins cross country make strides at Central Park Invitational

0

The Los Alamitos High girls cross country team posted an 11th place finish amongst a field of 35 teams and runners from more than 10 other schools that did not have enough runners to post team scores.

The Griffins were led by sophomore Caris Honma, who finished 53rd overall with a time of 19 minutes, 15.9 seconds. Senior Trista Candiotty was right behind her with a time of 19:18. Freshman Mio Emi was the third Griffin runner with a time of 19:39. Senior Alejandra Reyburn was fourth for the Griffins with a time of 19:46.8.

In the varsity boys race, junior Matthew Mayhue led the Griffins with a time of 15:56.6. He was followed by Sully Pareti, who finished in a time of 16:08.7. The Griffins’ JV team brought in a seventh place team finish, led by Sicely Johnston and Amina Farki, who were the top two runners for the team.

The Los Al girls sophomore team took second place in their division, with Remy Hoang leading the way with a 16th place overall finish. Bella Castellon was 21st overall and Audrey Delgaldillo was 27th overall for the Griffins top 3. Lauren Criscione and Hailey Mellott rounded out the Griffins’ scoring runners.

Photo by Ted Apodaca
Caris Honma led the Los Al varsity girls, finishing 53rd overall

The Los Al freshman boys team took third place in their race with all five scoring runners finishing in the top 50 scoring places. Dylan Lobo led the way with a 15th place finish in a time of 17:19.9. Sam Berry took 25th and Tyler Tanimura was 28th to lead the Griffins. Will Thomas and Sebastian Martinez were the final two scoring runners.

Among those individual runners was Irvine High’s Summer Wilson, who led the girls varsity field with a first-place finish in a time of 16 minutes, 19.4 seconds. The junior was more than 16 seconds faster than Millie Bayles of Trabuco Hills, who led the Mustangs to the team title with a time of 16:36.1.

Trabuco Hills won the team title, followed by Woodbridge High and Redondo Union High. Another individual runner, Sophie Hufton, of St. Catherine’s High School, took fourth overall.

Kennedy plays selfless in route to big way

0

Kennedy High scored three touchdowns in the final two minutes of the first half to turn a close game into a convincing win, as the Fighting Irish defeated Valencia, 34-19, in the Lambda League football opener for both teams on Friday at Handel Stadium.

Leading 7-0 with less than two minutes remaining in the second quarter, Derek Almazan hit Mahseiah Banks down the right sideline for an 85-yard touchdown pass that gave Kennedy a 13-0 lead. Kennedy forced Valencia to punt and again they struck quickly.

Devin Almazan was at quarterback and scrambled to his left before lobbing a shovel pass to Isaac Talamantes in the flat. The edge defender was being blocked so Talamantes went inside to get around the block and outran the defenders to sideline for a 67-yard touchdown and a 19-0 lead.

On the ensuing kickoff, the Kennedy cover team forced a fumble on the return and the Fighting Irish took over at the Valencia nine yard line. Derek Almazan soon found Talamantes again, this time for a nine-yard touchdown reception. Almazan converted a two-point conversion pass to Rocco Street and the Fighting Irish took a 27-0 lead into halftime.

Late in the third quarter, Talamantes would hit paydirt again, as he broke through a big hole in the line and cut around the safety to race 70 yards up the middle of the field for a touchdown and a 34-0 Irish lead. Valencia would score a touchdown late in the third and another late in the fourth to close the gap. Kennedy Head Coach Dan Urbanos was pleased with his team’s performance, which put them at 4-2 overall and 1-0 in Lambda League play.

“We played selfless football tonight, so we believe we’ve got a really quality team and we haven’t played our best football yet, you know, we’ve shown some flashes but really our biggest nemesis has been us,” Urbanos said.

Derek and Devin Almazan combined to throw for 218 yards and three touchdowns and Devin also ran for another. Talamantes led the ground game with 94 yards and a touchdown, while also catching two touchdown passes. Rocco Street and Riley Schow each had seven tackles on defense and Street added a quarterback sack. Moa Moimoi also had a sack. Makhell Beatty had three tackles and also blocked a field goal attempt to help keep Valencia scoreless in the first half.

The Fighting Irish travel to Fullerton High on Friday for a 7 p.m. game against the Indians, who are 0-6 and 0-1 after a loss to Beckman last week.

Griffins take home two prizes at Theater Fest

A poster for Lightning Thief.
Courtesy photo

On Saturday, 19 members of the Los Alamitos High Drama Department competed at the Role About Theatre Festival at Woodbridge High School. The event included 32 schools and more than 720 students who competed in various competitions in different performance and technical categories.

Los Alamitos had five students reach the finals of their categories and two of those brought home top prizes. Throughout the event, Drama Department advisor Stacy Castiglione said the students were at their best.
“As always, our students presented themselves professionally and graciously, as our theme this year is, ‘What are you doing to raise the room?’” Castiglione said.

Finals round participants:
• Leo Athy – Solo Musical
• Lily Martinez – Dramatic Monologues
• Sean Morin – Film/TV Monologues
• Laila Rain Montana – Comic Monologues
• Mason Potter – Film/TV Monologues
Laila Rain Montana took 1st place in Comic Monologues category and Mason Potter took 2nd place in Film/TV Monologues competition.

Courtesy photo
Students from Los Al High attending the event.

Pacific Airshow flies into OC this weekend

Pacific Airshow Huntington Beach has announced an expanded performer lineup, stacking the three-day spectacle in the sky with the best in aviation, October 4-6, 2024. Along with the previously announced headlining U.S. Air Force Thunderbirds and fan-favorite F-22 Raptor Demonstration Team, Pacific Airshow Huntington Beach will be the site for the last performance ever of the U.S. Air Force A-10 Demo Team, according to a Pacific Airshow press release.

In its eighth year, Pacific Airshow Huntington Beach is continuing to amp up the action in the air and on the sand by building a world-first temporary landing area on the beach to bring attendees and their families up close and personal with five STOL aircraft at this year’s Airshow. Amongst the STOL pilots attending is Luke Czepiela who famously landed on top of the Burj Al Arab skyscraper in Dubai last year. Attendees can witness non-stop sky-high stunts, fast flyovers and take part in expanded beach based fun and entertainment – including the return of Maverick and Iceman on the sand.

“Our team will be delivering on our commitment to produce a bigger and better experience each year, bringing our audience closer than ever to the best of aviation,” said Kevin Elliott, Pacific Airshow’s Executive Director. “When we say our vision is to redefine the Airshow experience, we mean it, and we are delivering an experience unlike any other event anywhere in the world.”

Additional military performers announced include the U.S. Navy F-35C Demo Team, U.S. Navy F/A-18 Rhino Demo Team, U.S. Navy EA-18G Growler Legacy Team, Louisiana Air National Guard Bayou Militia F-15s, U.S. Army Blackhawk and Lakota Helicopters, U.S. Navy Leap Frogs, U.S. Air Force Heritage Flight, U.S. Navy Legacy Flight, U.S. Marine Corps MV-22 Demo, U.S. Air Force C-17 West Coast Demo Team and U.S. Air Force KC-135 Demo Team.

Civilian performances include the Patriots Jet Team, Michael Goulian in the Extra 330SC, Franky Zapata flying both his Flyboard and Airscooter, Jeff Boerboon in the Extra 330SC, Scott Urshel in the Bo-105 Aerobatic Helicopter, Scaled Composites, FedEx 757, two Ace Maker T-33 jets, Rob Holland in the MXS-RH, The Horseman P-51s, Torrey Ward in the Microjet, the C-47 Dakota “Willa Dean” from the Lyon Air Museum and extreme sports stuntman Jacko Strong all the way from Australia.
“Pacific Airshow’s social and economic impact on the community is unmatched and every year brings our community together for a family friendly, patriotic celebration complete with world class aviation displays right on our coastline,” said Gracey Van Der Mark, Mayor of Huntington Beach. “We’re thrilled to have Pacific Airshow return to the skies over Huntington Beach this year for Southern California to enjoy.”

Tickets are on-sale now, offering General Admission, Pier Seating, Premiere Club, Private Chalet and Cabana options for all to experience the best views and ultimate thrill from the best vantage points. VisitPacificAirshow.com.

Cypress transitions to body-worn cameras, automated license plate readers

Personnel in the Cypress Police Department are now wearing body-worn cameras, Police Chief Mark Lauderback told the City Council on Monday.

In addition, Lauderback thanked the Cypress Police Foundation for a donation of $49,700 which the police chief said the department will use to install eight automatic license plate readers around the city.

Lauderback thanked the Foundation for “being a great partner to the city,” saying the Cypress Police Foundation’s contribution “will enhance public safety” by adding another layer of security to the mobile license plate readers that currently roll in each of the CPD’a police cruisers.

According to the city’s staff report, the donation will allow the department to go under contract with Insight IT Public Sector Solutions, to license and install the eight cameras, The donated cameras will be provided using a subscription-based model costing $3,000 per camera per year. This cost includes all hardware, software, and connectivity.

“This will complete the project with eight stationary Automated License Plate Readers cameras throughout the city,” the police chief said.

“It will help with investigations, identify vehicles used in crimes and they will be strategically placed throughout the city. A couple of them will be in our business park, which you know, our business park is vital to our city.”

With the business park mostly closed in the evenings and on weekends, “that does unfortunately lead to some criminal activity, or at least an invitation to commit criminal activity,” Lauderback said.

“With these ALPR cameras, we’re going to be able to use them as investigative tools to help identify those who committed the crimes, especially the vehicles, not only in our city, but throughout Orange County and our neighboring cities as well.”

Regarding the body-worn cameras, Lauderback asked an officer to demonstrate what it looks like when officers wear the cameras, and the police chief briefly explained how they work “to capture the interactions with our community, with those suspects or potential suspects we’re investigating.”

“It’s a great tool,” Lauderback told the Council and the department began using it last week.

He said the clarity is “awesome” and Lauderback thanked the city for allowing the department to purchase them.

The mayor also thanked the Cypress Police Foundation.

“We can’t thank the Foundation enough for their support of this department,” said Mayor Scott Minikus.

“I know the body-worn cameras have produced a lot of liability for cities around our nation, but as a whole, it is a great addition to our officers,” he added.

“It helps protect them against unscrupulous internal affairs complaints as well,” the mayor added.. “I t is a great reassurance tool for the officers to wear out there in the field,” the mayor said.

Edwin Kraemer, a Cypress resident who works as a software engineer (including artificial intelligence) for a major aerospace firm, expressed concern that the deployment of surveillance technology by Cypress Police has the potential for misuse.

“I would like to see more focus in the discussion of citizen’s access to that footage and its availability to the public,” said Kraemer during the Council’s oral communications session.

“When you put automated license plate readers in the neighborhoods or anywhere, every car that goes past that thing gets scanned and it can see everyone. You can track a person, you don’t need their social security number, you don’t need their face print, you get the car registration, and you’ll know everywhere that car has been,” he said.

“You will know everywhere that person has been from the time you install that camera until…forever, okay,” said Kraemer.

So what you’re putting in there is the ability to track every U.S. citizen, everywhere they go, easily, and that needs huge controls,” the engineer said, “so I want to hear what we’re doing to assure they are extremely careful with oversight of that because you can track within 100 yards of everywhere.”

“I’m sure it’s great for cops, but over half our budget goes to police. We’re a police state here,” said Kraemer.

Unlike in some other cities, city officials in Cypress do not respond to questions asked by citizens during the oral communications portion of the meeting.

After the meeting, Kraemer said that he did not expect an answer to his concerns, but as an AI engineer, felt he should at least warn citizens of the technology’s potential.

“I’m not for defunding the police,” he said in an interview after the meeting, “but citizens should know that using artificial intelligence coupled, with surveillance technologies, police could potentially have the ability to know not only where your car went, but what you purchased while there.”

Nevertheless, there is no immediate concern that Cypress Police have any plans to misuse the technology, said Kraemer, but “all I can do is ask them to put firm controls in place.”

Jewish Long Beach sets Oct. 7 commemoration

Jewish Long Beach is inviting the community to come together at the Alpert Jewish Community Center (JCC) on Monday, October 7, 2024, to commemorate one year since the attack in Israel that shattered the global Jewish community’s sense of safety.
This gathering will offer space to mourn the lives lost, pray for the hostages, pay tribute to the heroes defending the people of Israel, and reaffirm the community’s strength and commitment to Israel.

“The devastating harm Hamas unleashed on the Jewish people will never be erased,” said Deborah Goldfarb, CEO of Jewish Long Beach. “At a time like this, the most powerful thing we can do is unite as a community. Our strength lies in standing together, and only through collective action will we heal.”
The terrorist organization Hamas attacked Israel, killing over 1,200 innocent people, and captured over 250 people as hostages on October 7, 2023.

Guest speaker Lone Soldier Barak Moritz, from the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) 7th Armed Brigade, will share his experience engaged in the fight against Hamas. A Lone Soldier is a soldier in the IDF with no family in Israel to support them. Moritz grew up in Long Island, NY, and moved to Israel with his family at age 10. At age 18, he was drafted into the IDF as a paratrooper and placed in the Palsar unit assigned to the 7th Armed Brigade. Palsar units specialize in reconnaissance, advanced weapons, and special intelligence. He was living in San Diego when Hamas attacked on October 7th, and returned to Israel immediately upon learning that his company was called to service.

The commemoration event will begin at 7 pm at the Alpert JCC (3801 E. Willow St., Long Beach). Reservations are strongly recommended. Visit https://jewishlongbeach.regfox.com/october-7th-commemoration for more information and to register. No backpacks or large bags will be allowed inside. Clear bags that are equal to or smaller than 12” x 6” x 12”. Small clutches that are 9” X 6” are permitted and do not need to be clear.

Earlier in the day, the Alpert JCC will be hosting a reflection space from 8 – 11:30 am open-house style with refreshments, an instrumentalist, prayer and reflection activities, a photo gallery of Israel from that day, and a support counselor from Jewish Family & Children’s Service for anyone in the community looking for solace.
The Alpert JCC is located on the Weinberg Jewish Long Beach Campus, providing programming for all ages and stages of life.

Los Al Rec to offer watercolor painting classes for $120

The Los Alamitos Recreation and Community Services Department would like to invite you to participate in Watercolor Painting with instructor Darshini Aithal! In this class, participants will learn watercolor painting skills, techniques, and be equipped to increase their artistic ability. The basics of materials, tools, techniques, and color will be explored with demonstrations. If you are looking to learn tips and tricks in watercolors and would like to create your own beautiful masterpieces, this class is for you! This is a great class for those who are in the beginner to intermediate skill level.

There are two different programs available. These programs are four weeks long for ages 16 and over and will take place at the Los Alamitos Community Center (10911 Oak St.). The first program is on Mondays from 10:15 a.m. to 12:15 p.m., taking place from October 21 through November 18. There will be no class on November 11. The second program is on Saturdays from 10:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m., taking place from November 2 to November 23. The price for each program is $120 for residents and $125 for non-residents of Los Alamitos. All participants will be required to provide their own supplies; a list of supplies will be sent.

We hope to have you join us! For more information, please visit www.cityoflosalamitos.org/recreation or contact the Recreation and Community Services Department at (562) 430 – 1073.

La Palma Cerritos branch of AAUW enjoy Potluck dinner

Nineteen members of the La Palma-Cerritos Branch of the American Association of University Women (AAUW) met on Thursday, September 19, 2024, at the “Den” at Heritage Park in Cerritos, to enjoy an International Potluck and to make plans for the year. After members enjoyed trying the different ethnic food, Administrative Assistant Harriet Moses asked the leaders of the different Interest Groups to explain their group and encouraged new members to join. Members are asked to use contact information for the leaders of the groups in the Branch Directory that was distributed by Treasurer Marilyn Forsstrom at this evening meeting.

Gourmet Group Chair Joan Flax said that there will be three dinners planned for the third Saturdays of the month on October, January, and March, with a fourth one planned for the entire group and the end of the year. Contact Joan Flax for host houses, dates, times, and menus.

Great Decisions Chair Dorothy Edwards announced that there will be two more meetings this year, with the topic being “High Seas” in September, and “The Pandemic” in October. Meetings will be held on the fourth Wednesday of the month at 1:00 p.m., at Dorothy’s home. A new series will begin in January.

Readers Theater Chair Esther Aronson announced that all the meeting this year will take place at her home on the first Thursdays of the month starting at 6:30 p.m. with reading of plays at 6:45 p.m. Members take turns bringing snacks and there are fees for membership in the group and for postage for the play booklets. The first meeting will be on Thursday, October 3, 2024. Contact Esther for more information.

Cover to Cover Chair Thea Siegel announced that this group will meet different locations for book discussions each month on the second Thursdays of the month, starting at 1:00 p.m. Member Mary Ann Quinn will be hosting the October 10 meeting in home. Contact Thea for the locations of future Cover to Cover meetings.

After the Interest Group leaders finished discussing their groups, Harriet announced that the October Program will feature Margo Reed, a speaker from the League of Women Voters, who will be giving information about the 12 propositions that will be voted on in the November elections. She then received reports from appointed committee chairs of the branches’ committees.

Public Policy Chair Sondra Cohen provided handouts for the AAUW California State Public Policy Priorities for 2023-205, the 2024 Ballot Positions which AAUW takes a stand, and a 2024 Voter Guide for the candidates running for the 45th Congressional District in which the majority of our branch member live. Sondra urged members to sign up for the online Action Alerts which addresses California AAUW issues, and also the online wo-Minute Activist which addresses AAUW National issues.

For the AAUW Fund, Gail Ross volunteered to serve temporarily as the AAUW Fund Chair. Gail and Thea Seigel said that there are several options available for fundraisers with different restaurants that can be arranged that will help raise funds. Gail said the Fundraising Cruise to Catlina and Ensenada in February will also raise funds for the AAUW Fund. Joan Flax said that her Jewelry Sale on November 9 will be a ”mini fundraiser” for AAUW Fund. Contact Gail or Joan Flax for more information.

Since there is no Membership VP, Joan Plyman volunteered to help with membership duties and helped members to sign the attendance sheet for this meeting.. She also helped to deliver to members the new Branch Directory which was prepared by Marilyn Forsstrom. Joan also volunteered to take charge of Falcons Nest at Cerritos Community College which helps provide students with personal needs. Joan will be collecting donations of cosmetics, lotions, sanitary supplies, other personal needs, and clothing, at the October 17 meeting. Contact Joan for more information.

Celia Spitzer did a great job of arranging for the meeting to be held at “The Den” at Heritage Park. She thanked Sue Carruthers for her hospitality and providing decorations, paper goods, utensils, and water for today’s meeting.

Pictured at the La Palma-Cerritos Branch of the AAUW’s International Potluck on September 19, 2024, at Heritage Park in Cerritos, is Hospitality Assistant Sue Carruthers next to the desserts that were provided by members.

Administrator Harriet invited members to share a piece of good news about their families while donating $1.00 for the AAUW Fund. Five members responded and shared good news about their children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren!

At the end of the evening, Harriet said that our branch meetings will be held on the third Thursday of each month at the ABC Unified School District Adult School Auditorium at 20122 Cabrillo Lane, Cerritos, CA. with Social Time at 6:30 p.m. and guest speakers at 7:00 p.m. followed by business meetings. Her final announcement was that the January 16 meeting will be changed to January 15.

Members and guests are reminded to come to ABCUSD Adult School Auditorium on October 17, 2024, to come at 7:00 p.m., to hear Speaker Margo Reed from the League of Women Voters on the topic of the 12 Propositions that will be voted on in November.
For more information about the La Palma-Cerritos Branch of the AAUW, contact Administrator Harriet Moses at 714-994-1487.

Are incumbent no shows are disrepectful?

Dear Editor,

The RHA Candidate Night Forum in Rossmoor last week was informative, and many thanks to the Rossmoor Homeowners Association for sponsoring this event every election cycle. What struck me in particular were the candidate forums for the 45th Congressional District, and the 1st Orange County Supervisorial District. Both featured one of the candidates, and an empty chair.

For the Congressional race, challenger Derek Tran was present to make opening and closing statements, and to answer questions submitted to the moderators; Congresswoman Michelle Steel was absent. For County Supervisor, challenger Frances Marquez was also present to introduce herself and answer questions; Supervisor Janet Nguyen was absent.

Why the incumbents failed to show up is unclear. Maybe they were afraid to answer hard questions, or maybe they felt that their status as incumbents gives them a pass. Either way, their absence was notable, and might reasonably warrant a vote of no confidence.
Michael V. Sanders
Rossmoor

Rossmoor deserves better leadership

Dear Editor

Our vote is the only way we can stop the Rossmoor Community Service District’s deceptive and authoritarian approach to governing that has been a hallmark of the service district under the revolving leadership of Tony DeMarco, Michael Maynard, and Jeffrey Barke.

A glaring example of DeMarco’s poor leadership and subterfuge played out when he steamrolled over previous commitments for capital improvements at Rossmoor Park dating back to 2019 and 2020 (canopy and playground) and gave Pickleball priority, placing it steps away from homes in a small neighborhood park, against all sound reasoning.

First and foremost, at public hearings, the community was told for months that PB courts would be built with state grant money. There was never any grant money – in fact, PB was never even budgeted for – but DeMarco, along with Maynard & Barke, broke their promise to the community and voted to proceed with PB anyway.

Director DeMarco, displaying a stunning lack of due diligence, determined that noise, traffic and congestion weren’t a problem because he didn’t personally witness problems to that effect. In fact, there were many factors to consider regarding impact to the community; parking/traffic/safety along Hedwig/Foster, which sees 6,000 vehicles a day; no measuring of days/hours of peak play, number of players, resident vs nonresident activity, walk-ons vs paid, and any sort of concrete financial analysis.

The board did hire a sound consultant, but because the consultant’s study was limited to a single snapshot in time, and the “sound study” did not provide full data as to decibel levels – no doubt because the RCSD didn’t want to pay for a more thorough study – the RCSD purchased a $50 decibel reader from Staples and had an untrained park employee record the decibel level of PB at various times, declaring, in technical speak, “It’s hard to measure, but it’s not that loud.”

Director DeMarco then VOTED TO RESURFACE THE BASKETBALL AND TENNIS COURTS 2 – 4 YEARS EARLIER THAN NECESSARY because it was the only way they could paint the surface of PB courts under the guise of “doing it all at once.”

The deception continued when the Budget Committee, chaired by DeMarco & Maynard, created a $50,000 budget allocation out of thin air a few weeks before the PB vote, ultimately spending almost twice that, and all without effective sound mitigation.
DeMarco refused to recognize that dozens of PB courts are within a 2-mile radius, but, rather, because a minority of Rossmoor residents were too burdened to travel 1 or 2 miles outside of Rossmoor, he felt placing PB, literally, just steps from homes was warranted – despite every reputable sound consultant’s advice that residential homes should be no closer than 300 to 500 feet from PB. Director DeMarco compared his vision of Rossmoor Park to Lexington Park in Cypress, which has a parking lot with 244 parking spots, while Rossmoor Park has no parking lot at all.

DeMarco invited neighbors around the park to voice their complaints as the only way they’ll know if PB is intrusive, and then when dozens of complaints came pouring in, DeMarco decided they were irrelevant because a lot of them were from the same people (as in the park neighbors and tennis players using the courts).

Director DeMarco ignored the advice of a local real estate economist who said homes that close to PB courts could result in loss of value, saying he just didn’t believe it.
This has never been about whether PB is a fun, family-friendly, healthy sport. Everyone agrees it is. It’s about responsible leadership, transparency, and commitment to the community as a whole. PB never belonged in a small residential park so close to homes, and every bit of objective data from across the country made that clear to Directors DeMarco, Maynard & Barke, and they did not care.

Although this comment focused mostly on Rossmoor Park and PB, it is emblematic of irresponsibility that may affect other areas of RCSD’s supervision and, hence, affects potentially many other Rossmoor residents in the future.
Respectfully,
Michele Fieldson
Rossmoor

Griffins finish tourney with three straight wins

The Los Alamitos High boys water polo team finished the S&R Sport Tournament with three wins to capture a ninth place finish. The Griffins battled for one-goal wins over Palos Verdes and Crean Lutheran before finishing the tournament with a 12-9 win over Orange Lutheran.

The field of 16 teams included some of the top teams in the CIF-SS rankings. Eventual winner Corona del Mar is ranked third in the section rankings on MaxPreps. Los Alamitos is ranked No. 26, two spots ahead of Huntington Beach, the only team to beat the Griffins in their four tournament matches.

The Griffins will have to deal with both Huntington Beach and Corona del Mar as they had back into Sunset League play this week. The Griffins faced Newport Harbor, the top ranked team in the Southern Section, on Wednesday. They will get another shot at Huntington Beach on Oct. 9 at 5:15 p.m. at Los Alamitos High.

In a game that looked so promising that it was chosen to be televised live on Bally’s Sports Network, things could not have gone much worse for the Los Alamitos High football team.

The Griffins, ranked No. 15 in the state, were hosting Serra of Gardena, ranked No. 19 in the state in a Homecoming showdown that looked like Clash of Titans.
But the Serra Cavaliers took control early and ran away with a 42-7 win over the Griffins that had Los Al Head Coach Ray Fenton at a loss for words about what went wrong.
“We’ll look at the film tomorrow and try to figure it out,” Fenton said.

Serra, a small private school, has built up a top-level team over the years, winning CIF-SS championships as recently as Division 3 title in 2021. In the matchup against the Griffins, the game started somewhat routine, with each team punting after their first possession. But thing turned quickly as the Cavaliers struck on the first play of their second possession. Quarterback Jimmy Butler hit Malachi Holt for a 67-yard touchdown that put the Cavaliers up 7-0.

On the Griffins ensuing possession, the Cavaliers’ Marcellous Ryan intercepted a pass and returned in for a touchdown that extended the lead to 14-0 with 6:34 left in the first quarter. The Cavaliers extended the lead with another touchdown drive and a second pick six by Tre Harrison that gave Serra a 28-0 lead.

The Griffins began to move the ball on the ground, with Lenny Ibarra breaking off a few solid runs. But the Griffins still trailed 35-0 at halftime, thanks to another big pass touchdown by Serra. The Griffins opened the second half with their only scoring drive, sparked by a big run by Ibarra, after which he punched it in on a short run to cut the lead to 35-7.

The Griffins will try to rebound with another tough test as they travel to Lincoln High of San Diego on Saturday for a 1 p.m. game. The Hornets (3-2) are coming off a 49-19 win over Grant High and are ranked No. 16 in the MaxPreps State rankings. The Griffins (4-2) dropped three spots to No. 18. The Griffins open Alpha League play on Oct. 18 against

Edison at Huntington Beach High.

Kennedy, Cypress open league play

The Kennedy High football team heads into Lambda League with a 3-2 record, after falling to Irvine High, 28-14 on Friday. The Fighting Irish open the new league with a familiar foe in Valencia High, which moved from the Empire League along with Kennedy.

The Tigers also come into Lambda League play with a 3-2 record. The Fighting Irish defeated the Tigers 42-17 in last years league game. The Fighting Irish had rushing touchdowns by Derek Almazan and Isaac Talamantes, but could not overtake Irvine, despite leading them in all-purpose yards, 329-238. Deon Bynum had 136 yards on kick returns to spark the Irish, but the Irish offense was limited as the Vaqueros intercepted two passes and had a fumble recovery.

Kennedy hosts Valencia on Friday at Handel Stadium at 7 p.m.
Cypress High enters Delta League play on Friday, also with a familiar foe, as the Centurions will take on the Tustin Tillers, who moved from the Empire League to the Delta League. Both teams are coming off a bye week, with the Centurions (2-3) suffering a 42-7 loss to Tesoro High, and the Tillers (4-1) finishing non-league with a 35-31 loss to Yorba Linda High. The 31 points in the loss are the lowest amount of points the Tillers have scored this season. The two team will kick off at 7 p.m. on Friday at Tustin High.

Striking The Right Balance on Development in Cypress

By Kyle Chang

The future development of the Los Alamitos Race Course land represents one of the greatest economic opportunities for the City of Cypress. Not only is it the planned site for new housing units to help fulfill the requirements of the Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA), but it’s also the location for the Cypress Town Center. I firmly believe we can meet the goals of the RHNA and fulfill our moral responsibility to create more housing, but without careful planning and strong community engagement, we risk missing a golden opportunity to also create a true town center in our city.

As a parent with two young children, I would love to see Cypress create a vibrant city center that attracts new businesses, restaurants, and retail, transforming it into a destination that draws visitors from neighboring cities. That’s why before moving forward with any more plans or zoning changes for the Los Alamitos Race Course land, I propose establishing a new commission focused on planning, housing, and development to ensure the that we have a more transparent, inclusive planning process in Cypress. Many neighboring cities in Orange County, similar in size to Cypress (such as Buena Park, Stanton, and Fountain Valley), already have such commissions in place.

One of the most significant issues facing our city is the lack of clear communication with residents and not giving residents sufficient opportunities to be involved in important decisions. For example, with the update of the city’s housing plan, most residents are only learning about the details of the plan for the first time now, just before they’re asked to vote on it. Many residents at council meetings have said that they feel as though the city has deliberately withheld information or misled residents.

Additionally, the city has used scare tactics, claiming that if the ballot measure isn’t approved, “the State will override local governments and impose housing projects” and that the city risks “losing local control of planning decisions.” The truth is we already have an alternative housing plan that meets all of the state’s requirements and does not require a ballot measure. Our city must improve its communication with residents and more actively include them in major decisions that impact the future of our community. Any planning that requires community approval is destined to fail if the community isn’t involved in the planning process from the start.

The development of the Los Alamitos Race Course land is a defining moment for Cypress. By prioritizing transparency, honest communication, and active resident engagement, we can create a city center that meets our needs and enhances our community while complying with state housing mandates. It’s essential that we approach this project thoughtfully to ensure it benefits everyone in Cypress and aligns with our collective vision for a brighter tomorrow.

Editor’s Note: Views of any candidate are welcome so long as meet the editorial standards of thisn newspaper. Send submissions to ed****@******************se.com.

 

The City of Cypress needs a Planning Commission

By Blaze Bhence

How A Planning Commission Can Empower Residents In Cypress

In the vibrant tapestry of Southern California cities, Cypress stands out—not for its sun-soaked beaches or bustling nightlife, but for its absence of a city planning commission. This gap in our city governance might seem minor, but it carries significant implications for our future.

The old adage, “If you don’t have a plan, you plan to fail,” is particularly relevant in urban development. As one of the few Southern Californian cities without a dedicated planning commission, Cypress lacks something that is present in many other communities – a body comprised of local residents that is specifically tasked with evaluating and directing development. The absence of a planning commission can lead to missed opportunities and suboptimal outcomes for both residents and businesses.

At a recent public meeting the city’s planning director said that a planning commission for Cypress had been considered in the 1990s, but never moved forward. Now that Cypress is faced with state-mandated housing and zoning changes, perhaps its time that we considered giving residents more seats at the table? There are many potential benefits to consider.

First, without a planning commission, development decisions in Cypress may lack coherence and strategic foresight. Projects might proceed without a comprehensive analysis of their impact on local infrastructure, community needs, and how they fit into the long-term vision of what residents what Cypress to look like 5, 10, or even 25 years from now. The lack of a thorough analysis by an independent group of residents can result in poorly designed developments that strain our city’s resources and finances. A planning commission could ensure that projects are systematically evaluated and contribute positively to Cypress’s growth.

Effective urban planning also requires a holistic view of how different elements of the city interact. Residential areas need to be balanced with commercial zones to promote economic vitality while maintaining a high quality of life. We can, and should balance residential housing with exciting new businesses, and appealing public spaces. Without a planning commission, Cypress may struggle to achieve this balance, leading to zoning conflicts, inadequate amenities, and developments that fail to meet our community’s evolving needs.

And who is better to focus on meeting our community’s needs than a group of residents who are deeply invested in our city? Cypress benefits from three highly effective commissions that have greatly contributed to the city and its residents. The Seniors Commission, Traffic Commission, and Parks and Recreation Commission have been established for decades, building valuable resources and support for their respective communities.

A planning commission is not merely a decision-making body; it is a forum for community engagement and an additional opportunity to give residents a voice in how their city grows and changes. Public hearings and advisory roles ensure that development aligns with community values and priorities. Without deep involvement from residents from conception of plan all the way to fruition, Cypress residents may feel disconnected from the planning process, leading to a lack of trust and potentially contentious outcomes.

This was evident in the recent informational meeting and public hearing that the city hosted regarding the ballot measure to change the zoning of the Los Alamitos Race Course. Many residents asked great questions and shared their views on the different options. But at the same time, a number of residents expressed distrust about the information they had received from the city.

Others wondered why they were not given more information sooner, when they could have advocated for alternative plans that do not concentrate so much housing in just one or two areas. As a candidate for city council in the upcoming November election, I believe that the sooner we give residents a chance to weigh in on questions of growth and development, the better.

With a robust planning commission, Cypress would be better positioned to seize opportunities for strategic growth, attracting the type of businesses our residents really want, enhancing public spaces, and foster sustainable development. A planning commission would better enable Cypress to proactively plan for our future, whether we’re talking about the Los Alamitos Race Course or the Lincoln Corridor

A planning commission could ensure that redevelopment efforts enhance local infrastructure, support surrounding businesses, and reflect the needs and desires of Cypress residents. And as traffic congestion and related safety issues become a growing concern—which many residents have expressed at city council meetings—we can look for ways to proactively improve traffic flow, and make our city even safer through thoughtful planning.

To some, the establishment of a planning commission in Cypress may sound like another layer of bureaucracy. But in truth, an independent, resident-led body can help lead the way toward more thoughtful, strategic, and inclusive growth. A planning commission would be an investment in our city’s future, enabling us to plan proactively rather than reactively, engage our community in the decision-making process, and ensure that our resources are used effectively.

It’s not merely about having a plan; it’s about having the right plan—crafted with insight, expertise, and community involvement. With a dedicated planning commission, Cypress can set a course for sustainable and prosperous development, ensuring that our city thrives for generations to come.

Editor’s note: We urge candidates in the 2024 election to send us submissions, including op-eds, letters to the editor, endorsements or any material that will comply with our standard election coverage standards.

 

 

 

Vote No on Measure X in Los Alamitos

On the Nov. 5 municipal ballot for the City of Los Alamitos, is a little know Ballot Measure known as “X”. I am encouraging a NO vote!

This was a last minute, poorly written by staff, item pushed at the last final opportunity to be added to the November 5 municipal ballot. There was No public opportunity for public discussion when it was taken up late at the August City Council Meeting. Despite debate in from of a nearly empty council chamber, the motion was approved 3-2 to appear on the ballot.

Six changes are sought in the City Charter seeking approval by a single yes/no vote. Despite the merits of the requested changes to the Charter, you can only vote once! While it is proposed to control the process for lobbyists for the City, it also seeks to limit campaign donations to Council candidates from $5,500 to $500. It also wants change of the current three terms to reset for current members adding three more terms due to the recent change in 2029 to Council Districts fro the prior city wide election of candidates.

This means in 2026 any candidate would be able to gain 3 new four year terms. Only one council member is completing 12 years; however the charter change will permit 24 straight years for that candidate, if elected.

The required council districting was purportedly to expand opportunities in cities. In Los Alamitos, since implementation, those advances have failed. Candidate competition has failed in two districts with only one candidate three times, only the minimum required candidates twice, and when on council member unfortunately passed away mid term, required recruitment and a two year appointment of an alternate.

This added Charter Amendment also requires an increase in election cost by 2/5ths. That additional cost was never reported to the public.

The City was taken to court as the current proposal fails to give voters the ability to individually vote on each Charter section change. That judicial request was rejected by the Judge. Voters are left one choice for all six amendments.

The pro or vote yes ballot statement was signed by a former from nearly a decade ago, and the President of the city police officers union, which just negotiated a multi year salary increase of 18 percent over the next five years.

As a signer to the Vote NO on measure “X”, proposal, this proposal needs to be rewritten where voters can consider each change separately and have a Public Hearing before it goes back to the voters for consideration. There is no rush and full understanding of each change should be given a hearing before the vote.

Dean Grose, retired council member.

Dean Grose

“In God We Trust”

Retired Los Alamitos Councilman

Chairman, Regional Military Affairs

Committee at the Joint Forces

Training Base, Los Alamitos

562-241-0235 cell

Los Al Chamber honors frontline heroes at “Heroes Luncheon”

The Rush Park auditorium in Rossmoor was filled to its capacity on Thursday as the community gathered to honor heroes in uniform at the 5th Annual Los Al Chamber’s “Heroes Appreciation Luncheon.”

Dr. Andrew Pulver, Supt. of the Los Alamitos Unified School District, served as Master of Ceremonies for the event and welcomed the large crowd with an opening “shout-out” to Judy Klabouch, a local businesswoman who dreamed up the event the year before the COVID pandemic.

Courtesy Photo
Dr. Andrew Pulver looks out into a sea of people as he welcomed the overflow crowd at Rush Park in Rossmoor.

Pulver said the heroes’ luncheon is purposely held in September as the nation pauses “to remember all of our different heroes.”

Tony Demarco, Vice President of the Rossmoor Community Services District, said “on behalf of the RCSD Board, we are pleased that this event is being held in our community. Also,” he said, “it amazing that we can “it’s so many people in here,” looking out over the overflow crowd.

The RCSD Board and community “join you in honoring our medical frontline workers and those in uniform for their bravery and courage,” said Demarco.

Pulver, too, asked the audience to give itself a hand for “the sold-out crowd.”

Following a color guard from Joint Forces Training Base, the national anthem was performed by Nathalie Hammond of the Los Al police Department. Pulver then introduced a long list of local and visiting VIP guests, including ranking military officials, elected officials and private sector CEO’s.

Assemblymember Tri Ta spoke briefly to “thank the Los Al Chamber of Commerce and RCSD for organizing this event. “It makes me feel so good to honor and show our appreciation to our first responders, to our men and women in uniform and those who have sacrificed for our freedom. “

Here are this year’s HEROES.
• California Army National Guard, Major An Vu.
• California Highway Patrol, Officer Edwin Lopez.
• Joint Forces Training Base 40th Infantry Division, Sgt. Alma Buerta.
• 79th Army National Guard Sustainment Command, Capt. William McGuigan.
• Los Alamitos Police Department, Officer Joel Espinoza.
• Orange County Fire Authority, Firefighter Blake Campbell.
• Orange County Sheriff’s Department, Deputy Ernesto “Ernie” Escobar.
• UCI Health Los Alamitos, Santiago Chambers.
• Seal Beach Navy Weapons Station, U.S. Navy, Lt. Luis A. Hernandez.

The Los Al Chamber and other local officials celebrate Blake Campbell, this year’s Hero from the OC Fire Authority, who could not be there because he was in the field fighting wildfires. Courtesy photo

One of this year’s heroes, Blake Cambell, of OCFA, could not be present because he was busy on the front lines fighting one of many wildfires ongoing in the state, officials said.

Each of this year’s Heroes went home with an engraved glass trophy, a Certificate of Recognition from the Chamber, and others including the City of Los Alamitos, Assembly members, Senators, Supervisors, and others.

The ENE will present the individual stories of this year’s Heroes in the weeks to come.

La Palma resident, City Manager, trade barbs after sign pulled

0

La Palma’s City Manager Connel McNamara is under scrutiny this week from a group of residents opposed to the city’s proposed ballot measure after he was personally seen removing a sign from a city right-of-way.

Robert Carruth, a financial services executive and a longtime La Palma resident, said he had a multi-day exchange with City Manager Conal McNamara following the incident.
Carruth frequently acts as a watchdog for residents. He and at least two former Mayors are now part of an ad-hoc group organized to oppose the city’s proposed ballot measure “W”, which, like the Los Alamitos ballot measure, would rewrite the city’s current term limit provision that would allow some Council members to stay in office for decades.

“I was just fortunate enough to be driving home from work that day and I saw him (McNamara) do it,” said Carruth. Carruth acknowledges the opponent’s sign was in an area of the Public Right of Way (PROW) that could have been determined to violate a city ordinance, but other signs were in similar places and not removed, said Carruth.
Carruth said after the incident, he followed the city manager back to City Hall and photographed him carrying the “No on W” sign into city hall.

In a email to La Palma Mayor Marshall Goodman, Carruth said “The City Manager’s action clearly and intentionally discriminated against a single group because the sign included speech that the City Manager and members of the City Council opposed.”
“The City Manager did not delegate the matter to Code Enforcement for the investigation and follow-up,” as written in the code, said Carruth. Instead, he took it upon himself to personally confiscate the sign.”

“Did he take this action independently or did a La Palma City Council member instruct him to remove the sign,” asked Carruth in the email.

In his response to Carruth, according to emails submitted to ENE, McNamara acknowledged picking up the “No on W” sign but explained it was because both the Code Enforcement officer and City Clerk were out of the office for various reasons.

“Unpermitted election signs are generally handled by the City Clerk,” explained McNamara, “as she has records and contact information for candidates and others putting up signs.”
“As you are aware, staff does not work on Fridays, Saturdays, or Sundays so (generally) no enforcement occurs during those times,” the city manager aid.

Courtesy Photo
The city manager said Code Enforcement handles political signs and realtor signs differently. This one sits in right of way.

“I removed it (No on “W” sign) because I saw it (in the PROW) and because Kimberly (City Clerk) was not at work,” the city manager said. McNamara also claimed that other signs in the right of way were real estate signs, not near where he removed the ballot measure sign.

“The two violations are not related,” he responded, “as I was unaware of your claim that there were realtor signs, in a different part of the City (again, we would not be removing realtor signs or election signs on the weekend as we do not have staff resources to do so),” said McNamara.

He said “sometimes new real estate agents do not know the City’s regulations and, because we are a business-friendly City, we try to work with them so that we do not have repeat violations.”

“I do not remove real estate signs because generally, Marion (Code Enforcement Officer) can address them in a timely manner,” he said.

Carruth said four of the current city council members voted in favor of a city ordinance that restricts public signs in rights of way in certain periods before elections.

“By this action, the city is advocating for the passage of Measure W by prohibiting opposition speech via temporary sign while allowing other speech via temporary signs during the restricted period,” said Carruth.

McNamara denied his actions constituted public advocacy on behalf of Measure W.
“City staff does not take a position on election-related matters nor is my action to remove an unpermitted campaign sign in broad daylight while wearing City logo branded clothing an indication of advocacy,” McNamara wrote, “because you believe a real estate sign in a different part of the City was not removed.”

“Had I removed an opposition sign to the measure but failed to remove a supportive sign that I had also seen, it would clearly be a different situation,” the city manager wrote in his detailed response to Carruth.

“As you state, it is well known that a supermajority of La Palma City Council members supported voter approval of Measure W; however, it is untrue that the City Manager has taken any position for or against the measure,” he wrote.

In his email to Mayor Marshall Goodman, Carruth also demanded the Mayor clarify whether the city was going to enforce its temporary sign ordinance fairly “or will it continue to discriminate against protected political speech that the city opposes.”

Goodman simply replied via email, according to emails forwarded to ENE by Carruth, “l
hope you are well. A staff member will get back to you in due time.”

Carruth said when confronted, McNamara rather than simply leave the sign at city hall for him to pick up, introduced the city’s police department to demonstrate the power he has over the staff.

Carruth said McNamara told him “he had already given it to the police and they’re keeping it at the station, so you can pick it up there.”

“You’re trying to intimidate me,” Carruth said he told McNamara, “instead of leaving it at the front counter of city hall, you’re making me go into the police station.”
“Why not leave it at City Hall,” asked Carruth.

Moreover, Carruth said when he followed McNamara’s instructions and went to the police department to pick up the Measure W sign Thursday evening, city police officials said they had no idea what Carruth was asking about.

Carruth said McNamara had already left his office at 5:30 p.m. Thursday, even though staff in the city purportedly work until 6:30 p.m. to enjoy perennial three-day weekends.
“He responded to my email saying, “I’m sorry, I dropped the ball, it’s my fault,” Carruth said McNamara told him. “We’ll have somebody drop it off at your house,” he said McNamara told him.

“Not necessary,” Carruth said he told McNamara, “I don’t want police officers coming to my house, I don’t need that. I’m happy to come and pick it up.”

“A few minutes later, a police officer knocks at my door. I told my wife, ‘that’s a form of manipulation and control,’” said Carruth. “I specially asked for this not to happen,” said Carruth, noting that the officer was courteous, but “it was specifically what I asked not to happen,” said Carruth.

Later this past weekend, Carruth forwarded a photo of a “Yes on W” sign erected in a public right of way.

“Basically, the city is changing the way they enforce the code,” said Carruth. “They voted for the new code in 2022, but now that it’s not convenient for their cause, they’re going to play games and maybe skirt the rules.”

“McNamara, who works for them, isn’t going to enforce the code the same way it was just two years ago, and if that is not discrimination, I don’t know what is,” he added.

The ENE has repeatedly reached out to McNamara and Goodman for additional comment but as yet, there has been no reply.